Scottish Marine and Freshwater Science Vol 11 No 11
Offshore renewables have the potential to make a significant contribution to the Scottish Government’s target to generate 50% of Scotland's overall energy consumption from renewable sources by 2030 and to have decarbonised the energy system almost completely by 2050. The offshore wind industry is set to expand substantially in Scotland and the rest of the UK over the next decade and beyond as both the Scottish and UK Governments strive for clean energy and climate change targets, and a green economic recovery. However, the Scottish Government has a duty to ensure that offshore renewable developments (ORDs) are achieved in a sustainable manner, by protecting habitats and species from adverse impacts.
Noise from offshore renewables, particularly in the construction phase, can disturb marine mammal species and the potential impact of any new development requires assessment. The interim Population Consequence of Disturbance (iPCoD) is a framework that allows individual-level effects from disturbance to be scaled to population-level impacts. However, the iPCoD framework relies on expert elicitation, which is a source of variability and uncertainty in outputs. Another approach, which has the potential to be integrated into the iPCoD model, is Dynamic Energy Budgets (DEBs) theory. Incorporation of DEB theory into the modelling process can be used to predict how behavioural and environmental changes (e.g. food availability) influence individual energy budgets and thus population vital rates. Consequently, DEBs have the potential to produce a more accurate and robust prediction of population-level impacts.
This report has developed dynamic energy budget (DEB) models for harbour porpoise, bottlenose dolphins, minke whales, harbour seals and grey seals in the UK based on values from current literature. It illustrates how a DEB model can be used to investigate the potential effects of disturbance that cause a reduction in energy intake, subsequently effecting vital rates (individual survival and birth rate), using harbour porpoise as an example. The report also highlights limitations in current knowledge and next steps in research to progress the DEB approach for these species and others.
This work represents a significant step towards a more empirical framework for marine mammal assessments to reduce uncertainty and, while some expert elicitation will still be necessary due to gaps in empirical knowledge, these models can provide a more detailed and robust assessment of population-level consequences of impact that will aid interpretation by advisors and decision makers.
The project was funded by Scottish Government (Marine Policy and Planning) as part of the Scottish Marine Energy Research programme and undertaken by SMRU Consulting.
Data and Resources
- Topic sheet - Developing marine mammal dynamic energy budget models and their potential for integration into the IPCOD frameworkpdf
Topic sheet associated with the report
|Release Date|| |
|Spatial / Geographical Coverage Location|| |
UK Open Government Licence (OGL)
|Data Dictionary|| |
The report describes in detail the different parameters that are required by a DEB model, which of those are likely to be found in or derived from the literature and which are unknown and require subjective judgement. Based on an extensive literature search, we provide suggested parameter values for harbour porpoise, bottlenose dolphins, minke whales, harbour seals and grey seals in the UK, noting in each case the literature that was used to derive the parameter and where they were estimated by subjective expert judgement. While recommended parameters were collated for each of the five species, a full DEB model was created for harbour porpoise only. Therefore, the focal species in this report is the harbour porpoise. The text details the results of the literature search for harbour porpoise and exactly how each parameter value was calculated or estimated. Similar detail is provided for bottlenose dolphins, minke whales, harbour seals and grey seals in Appendix 1-4.
|Contact Name|| |
|Public Access Level|| |